Choosing a work boot is no more an easy task. There are lots of different kinds of boots making you really confused about your decision. But if have made your mind upon buying an steel toe boot then just sit back and read our list of best steel toe boots. We have covered all the best boots that you show know in every range and categories to make your choice simple and straight.
Composite boots vs. Steel toe boots
Every time you think of buying a safety boot these are the top two categories that might comes to your mind. If you are confused about making a decision then don’t worry, we are here to help.
Composite boots are made with Kevlar, carbon fiber, or fiberglass. They are made with non-metal objects and steel toe boots are made with steel, aluminum or other such metals.
Safety – there is nothing better than steel toe boots when comes to safety. Because they are made with metal, they provide much higher resistance than composite boots. Though composite boot also provides fair bit of resistance, but it will break when higher pressure is applied. Therefore, if safety is your primary concern than choose steel toe boots.
Comfort – Composite boots are lighter than steel toe boots because of material used. They are more suitable for long hours. And if your work requires you to go through metal detector then you should choose composite boots. Another advantage with composite boots is they are not affected by the weather while steel toe boots can get cold in winter and hot in summer as steel is very good conductor of heat.
Finally, if safety is your concern go with steel toe boots and if comfort is your priority then you may opt for composite boots. Overall, they both are good work boots.
Steel toe boots reviews
1. Caterpillar Men’s Second Shift Steel Toe Work Boot
Caterpillar is few of the oldest and most trusted brands in safety shoe industry. They certainly know a thing or two more than other safety shoe brands. Their expertise and knowledge can be seen in Caterpillar men’s second steel toe work boot. This is amongst the best rated steel toe shoes in the market. It was first released over a decade ago and since then it’s always been a popular choice of safety worker’s.
There is no doubt that this is a heavy duty shoes, it will take little time for you to get used to this boot. Therefore, we recommend wearing them lightly for few days before going for long shifts. However, once you are passed those few days than you will know why these shoes are so popular.
Apart from round steel toe this boot is water resistance and has oil resistance traction outsole. But the boots are not insulated, therefore if you are working in very cold environment than this work boot is not very much recommended. Other than that, there is nothing significant negative about this steel toe work boot. It offers excellent comfort, best of best durability and great value for money.
- Amazing value for money
- Great durability
- Comfortable for long day at work
- Absence of insulation
- Water resistant but not water proof
2. GW Men’s 1606ST Steel Toe Work Boots
If you are looking for an excellent steel toe boot under $50, then we couldn’t recommend anything better than GW Men’s 1606ST Steel Toe Work Boots. It is a lower cut type of boot that is suitable for almost any weather condition. Its upper is made with genuine leather; it has Full-Grain Nubuck, Rubber Sole and steel toe. It prides itself in its durability.
This is a water resistance shoe, which means it can repel water but if it is submerged in water than water will find a way to get into the shoes. Another safety feature is slip resistance, which simply means it provide better grip on to the floor than other normal shoes.
Regarding comfort, this shoe is generally half a size wider than other normal shoes of same size. This particular quality has several benefits which includes – shoe will be a great fit for wide feet, you can wear thick socks in harsh winter without any discomfort. Even if you don’t wear thick socks and you don’t have wide feet, the additional width of the shoe won’t cause any discomfort.
Last but not the least it is probably the best steel toe shoes under $50. Its comfort, durability and toughness are nonparallel to any other work boot of the same price.
- Great value for money
- Excellent comfort
- Durable and strong
- Made with genuine lather
- It is not waterproof
- Stiffness takes little more than usual time to break
3. Skechers for Work Men’s 77009 Workshire Relaxed Fit Work Steel Toe Boot
Skechers is a big name in footwear world. They make some really stylish and comfortable sneakers. They are hugely popular in that segment but are they equally good in making work boots? Let’s find out –
This was the very first Skechers work boot that I bought from amazon.com. The one reason I brought this was because it was very stylish for a work boot, specially the wheat color. It looks exactly like it was mentioned on the site. After wearing this for couple of month I was pleasantly surprised by it comforts and quality. It is suitable for wide feet as it is little wider.
Its upper is made up of leather and has a rubber sole. For additional comfort it has memory foam which you generally don’t see at this price. For safety it has steel toe, many people are confused regarding steel but I can confirm the same. Apart for steel toe, it is also water and slips resistant. Another notable feature is its weight; it is very light in weight compare to few other steel toe boots.
Finally, it has received some great reviews on amazon.com (which actually compel me to buy this boot in first place). It has an overall rating of 4.2/5 stars by more than 250 users.
- Light in weight
- Comfortable and stylish
- Great hill size
- Water and slip resistance
- Skechers is yet to establish itself as a working boot brand
4. Timberland PRO Direct Attach 6″ Steel Safety Toe Waterproof Insulated Boot
It is a brand that needs no introduction. Timberland along with caterpillar is specialized in making great work boots. Every product from timberland are made with toughness in mind, I must admit I am a great fan of timberland product’s toughness and quality.
This shoe is also amongst my favourite steel toe shoe, though this is a bit pricey than other shoes in the list. But because of timberland’s quality, expertise and dependability this shoe worth spending few extra bucks.
It comes with Electrical hazard protection, Padded top collar for added comfort and Mesh lining with anti-microbial treatment for comfortable and odorless feet. Unlike previous boots this is a water proof and not water resistance, which is a great advantage in many situations.
It has PRO 24/7 Comfort Suspension System which claims to reduce foot fatigue, stabilized and disperses pressure. This boot is suitable to every weather condition. it keeps your feet warm in cold condition through built in insulation and cool in hot weather through its breathable outer material.
Overall, it has all the quality to be called a best steel toe boot. This is a dependable, comfortable and solid pair of boots from timberland.
- Amazing built and toughness
- Safety is given adequate importance
- PRO 24/7 Comfort Suspension System
- Insulation for keeping your feet warm
- A bit pricey
- Many customers complain of the size issue
5. SAFETY STEEL TOE Men’s Leather Work Boot
This is the cheapest steel toe boot in our list. Thought we won’t call it as the best steel toe boots but they offer great value for money. If you are looking for a cheap boot that provides basic safety and durability at a very affordable price, than this might be the right choice.
Its upper is made up of leather and sole is made up of rubber, similar to most work boots. For added durability it has double to triple stitching. This boot is equipped with Superior padded insulated linings which is really amazing because even our top product of caterpillar wasn’t equipped with insulated linings. This is also a water resistant boot.
Few negative things which that we would like to highlight are – first, it is not suitable for wide feet, the shoe is pretty narrow in size and many users complain of discomfort because of narrow gaping. Second, the rubber of this shoe smells really bad. Though the smell goes after few days but it did smell bad for first few days.
Apart from few negatives it is a very good steel toe shoe. It does punch above its weight. We would definitely recommend this for someone looking for a cheap steel toe shoes.
- Water resistant
- Superior padded insulated lining
- Best value for money
- Double to triple stitching
- Not suitable for people with wide feet
- Rubber smell awful at first
6. Stanley Men’s Dropper Steel-Toe Work Boot
This is another affordable steel toe boot from Stanley. Stanley has wide variety of work boots, and they have been pretty much consistent with their quality. They have large catalog of product and most of their product has been received positively by the consumers.
Like with most work shoes its upper is made up of leather, it has Dual-density EVA midsole with contrast stripes for better comfort. A good inclusion to the boot is removable EVA insole. It features a waterproof upper and Goodyear welt construction.
Apart from being waterproof it also has oil and slip resistance. This steel toe boot is also suitable for working in cold environment as it has built-in insulation. Last but not least, it meets ASTM standards F2413-11 and is rated I/75 and C/75, that also makes it safe for electric hazard.
The only major flaw that we could find was its calf circumference. The calf area is bigger than usual and thereafter makes it uncomfortable to walk, though you can tuck your pants in the shoe but it may look awkward. Overall, it has every feature required to be a great steel toe shoe. It is a reliable brand, affordable boot, waterproof upper, durable and comfortable.
- Removable EVA sole
- Keeps your feet warm in cold condition
- Build quality is good
- Calf area is bigger than usual
- Lack ability to tighten the shoe
7. Condor Men’s Dakota 8″ Steel Toe Wheat Nubuck Work Boot
This is quiet a newer product in our list. As a result, it’s not amongst the well-known boots in the list. However, it is amongst the best steel toe boots in the market and there are good reasons for that.
First of all, they are extremely well made boots with Genuine Nubuck Leather that provide a rich and smooth feel the shoes. At the bottom it has synthetic sole which holds up pretty decently on different floor types. It has AM-TECH® Direct Soling Technology which basically means that upper sole and outsole are bonded directly without using any glue or stitching. This creates an inseparable bond between two.
For added comfort and support for your feet it features very soft cushioning and flexible polyurethane. The boots are oil resistant, water resistant, slip resistant and scratch resistant. There is also a 12 month manufacturer warranty on this product. As you know that there is hardly any kind of warranty on work boots because of the environments they are generally used. But warranty on this product shows the confidence of then manufacturer.
Lastly, they have received extra ordinary reviews on amazon.com yet. There is not even a single negative review for any customer yet. The least one is 3/5 stars and rest of them are either 4 or 5 stars.
- Extremely good built quality
- Great support and comfort for your feet
- Water, oil and slip resistant
- Amazing response from the customers
- Relatively new boots to be reliable
- No mention about insulation
8. Golden Fox Steel Toe Men’s Lightweight Work Boots
This looks more like a stylish casual boot than a work boot. It is made up to leather and accompany by rubber sole for better grip on to the surface. There are two colors to choose from – Brun and redwood. Both of the colors are very stylish.
Thing that set it apart from most work boot is its lightweight. I don’t know if they are really lighter than others or not, but you certainly don’t feel any heaviness while wearing them. Weight distribution is done pretty well.
For safety, it has oil resistant outsole and removable insole for comfort. Thought they don’t look like heavyweight work shoes but they are pretty much durable for industrial work. It has double stitching on toe area for additional safety.
Drawbacks of golden fox steel boots are – they are not wide enough for your feet. If you have wide feet than you may have problem with fitting of this shoes. They are also not slip resistance and electric hazard resistance.
This is kind of shoes that are more suitable for light industrial work, stylish looking is an added advantage. And you are advised to order ½ sizes bigger than your usual boots.
- Stylish looking
- Oil and water resistance
- Great bargain
- Lightweight and comfortable
- No protection against slip and electric hazards
- Too narrow for wide feet
9. Dexter Men’s Douglas Steel Toe Work Boot
It is also a relatively new product compare to our other products. But it has very dependable built quality and trusted user ratings. They are made of synthetic leather. This is bit disappointing as most of our other steel toe boots are made of genuine leather, but somehow it manages to work just perfectly fine.
It also has rubber sole like every other steel boot and Memory foam insole to keep your feet comfortable. This is also water and oil repellent. This boots from Dexter Men’s are amongst the few good looking steel toe shoes, you can easily use them as your walking shoes. They are available in three colors – Chamois (its okay if have heard this color name for the first time, even I did when I brought them), brown and black.
They have got some really great reviews on amazon.com. Although because it’s a new product there are not many reviews but there are hardly any negative review. It has received 5/5 stars by more than 80% of the customers and has an overall rating of 4.4/5 stars.
Lastly, we would like to say that obviously there are few shortcomings of this product, but overall it is a great product at a really great price. We could definitely recommend you to buy this steel toe boot.
- Soft and comfortable leather
- Water and slip resistance
- Great for person with wide feet
- Large in size
10. Wolverine Men’s W08289 Wolverine steel toed Boot
After all those wonderful steel toe boots, here we comes to our last steel toe shoes of the list. This is a handmade shoe from wolverine. Wolverine also has quite a variety of good work boots. They are a respectable name in work boot industry.
This product of wolverine is made of full-grain leather; it has a synthetic sole and Shaft measuring 7 inches for the arc. This is also a water and slip resistance shoe. It has removable insole and they are equally good for wide feet, as there are many sizes to choose from.
One of the main reasons to include this boot in best steel toe boots was the comfort it provides to your feet. And another reason that dragged it down the list was its size, there are pretty huge in size which probably is its biggest disadvantage.
Other than that we couldn’t find any major disadvantage with this boots. They are pretty much perfect in their own. They have more than decent rating of 4.2/5 stars on amazon.com. While more than 50% of them have given it full 5/5 stars. Overall, if you don’t mind it little big size than this boots are very much recommended because of its comfort and toughness.
- Water and oil resistance
- Memory foam insole
- Can also be used as a casual boot
- Great feedback from the customers
- Relatively new product
- Lack of genuine leather
How to choose best steel toe boots
Comfort is the most important factor while buying a steel toe shoe. Always look for right fitting. A wrong fitting boot causes more injury than any accident. If you have wide feet than make sure that boot is wide enough to accommodate your feet.
Padding is another important feature to look after. Look for what kind of inner padding does boot offers. Is padding removable? Most boots have removable and replace inner padding, removable padding can also be replaced when it gets damage. Breathability is also important, especially in long work hours. Not only your feet become uncomfortable but it also creates a very foul smell. Therefore, it’s important that your boot uses breathable upper material.
After comfort the next important thing is quality. We all are tired of boots that doesn’t last longer than a month. Therefore, it is important to choose steel toe boots with good quality material. We normally prefer leather over any other material and rubber sole is best for better grip.
There are many types of leather available in the market. Make sure to buy one with genuine leather. Most of the boots we have highlighted in this list are made up of leather and rubber sole. Double stitching is always preferred over single stitch.
Most of buy steel toe boots for safety and quality. Therefore safety is the single most important thing and should not be avoided with any cost. One obvious feature in steel toe boots is steel toe. Apart from steel toe do look for waterproof or water resistance upper, oil resistance and slip resistance. These are three basic features that every good steel boot should have. Additional safety features are always welcomed and appreciated.
If you are living in or going to work in cold condition, then insulation will be a very handy feature. It will keep your feet warm and comfortable. Therefore, it is recommended to buy a work boot with insulation built-in.
Heel and padding
This is really a personal choice to make depending on condition you’re going to work. Some prefer ankle high boots and while other prefers flat boots. They both have certain pros and cons. Therefore, we ask users to choose one they feel comfortable with.